Should you eat Yogurt ?
It's
been reported that this fermented, slightly acidic semisolid
dairy product is useful, treating a variety of ills ranging from
canker sores to colon cancer.
Most
recently, a study was presented before the American College of
Gastroenterology finding that patients who consumed two 8-ounce
servings of vanilla yogurt a day had half the rate of
antibiotic-associated diarrhea compared with those who didn't eat
yogurt. Few question the validity and finding of this study, done
by researchers at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center —
McKeesport Hospital. "This finding isn't surprising to me,
since there has been evidence in the past that yogurt can help
prevent traveler's diarrhea and some types of food
poisoning," says Manfred Kroger, Ph.D., professor of Food
Science at The Pennsylvania State University and a leading
authority on yogurt and other dairy foods. "Basically, it's
been shown that people who consume a pint a day — 16 ounces —
before traveling are less likely to get Montezuma's revenge, Delhi
belly, Turkey trot, or whatever else you call it."
Yogurt
is believed to help quiet a kvetching colon because of those
"live cultures" ballyhooed on the container labels. To
be effective, says Kroger, yogurt must contain at least two
"friendly" bacteria — Lactobacillus bulgaricus and
Streptococcus thermophilus — that have been cultured with
milk or skim milk. These friendly bacteria help destroy hostile
bacteria, thus protecting you from food poisoning and illness that
can cause diarrhea and wreak other havoc, at least temporarily, on
your intestines.
"The
truth is, about 90 percent of these helpful bacteria are killed in
your stomach," he says. "But about 10 percent manage to
get through the small intestines and to the colon, where diarrhea
occurs.
"
But there's a big difference between killing bacteria and killing
cancer cells.
Several
years ago, news reports claimed that yogurt could fight colon
cancer, citing a study by the University of Southern California
School of Medicine. According to those reports, colon cancer
patients who consumed yogurt one to three times a month
strengthened their body's ability to fight the cancer more
effectively than patients who didn't eat yogurt.
"Those
reports drove me crazy," says epidemiologist Ruth Peters,
Sc.D., who headed the study. "What we found was that there
was a protective effect from consuming a diet that was rich in
calcium. Yogurt just happens to be among the best calcium sources
in our study. Is yogurt more protective than calcium from other
food sources? Is there something in yogurt other than calcium that
may be helpful? We don't know. We didn't study the yogurt, per se,
but that's how the media reported it."
And
it's not the first time.
Still,
reputations live on — even when they're not scientifically
documented. Yogurt has been cited by some, including doctors, for
helping to prevent and treat canker sores, yeast infections and
even rectal itch.
Should
you eat yogurt? Probably. It's a great source of protein,
riboflavin and calcium, an important nutrient that is lacking in
the diets of many — especially women. "Yogurt is so good it
gets its own mention on the Food Guide Pyramid that we all should
follow," notes Kroger.
Is
it a wonder food? Hard to say. "The problem is that the
claims are more numerous than the studies to back them up,"
adds Kroger. "I was a yogurt maker in Germany and I love
yogurt. But I'm also a scientist. Progress has been slow in
getting real scientific consensus based on many good studies that
are peer-reviewed. In the meantime, eat it — but don't expect
miracles."